Neighbor’s Little Daughter Left a Weird Gift for Me under the Fence – When I Saw What Was Inside, I Went Pale

Stephanie had always valued her independence. Living alone in her cozy little house for the past decade had its perks. It allowed her to pursue her passions, like gardening and painting. But it wasn’t always by choice.

After a painful divorce five years ago, Stephanie found solace in her quiet, solitary life. That was when the Thompsons moved in next door with their little girl, Emily.

Living next to the Thompsons was usually quiet. Their little daughter, Emily, was a silent six-year-old child. Over time, Stephanie realized she was mute. She often saw Emily playing alone in the yard, her eyes always scanning for something interesting, but she never made a sound.

One sunny Sunday, an ice cream truck came through the neighborhood, playing its cheerful tune. Emily ran out, her eyes wide with excitement. She stood at the edge of her yard, clutching the fence, watching the truck with longing.

Feeling a sudden wave of generosity, Stephanie walked over to her. “Hey there, Emily,” she said gently. “Do you want some ice cream?”

Emily looked up, her eyes sparkling with hope, and nodded vigorously.

“Alright then,” Stephanie smiled. “Come on, let’s get you some.”

They walked over to the truck together. The ice cream man leaned out, smiling. “What can I get for you today?”

Stephanie glanced down at Emily. “What would you like, sweetie?”

Emily pointed to a colorful popsicle.

“One popsicle, please,” Stephanie ordered. She handed over the money and took the treat, giving it to Emily.

Emily smiled up at her, nodding her thanks before hurrying back home with her treat. Stephanie watched her go, a warm feeling spreading in her chest.

A few days later, while watering her plants, Stephanie noticed something small under the fence that separated their yards. She bent down and saw it was a piece of paper with shaky handwriting that said “Thank you” and a piece of candy. Clearly, Emily was too young to write well, but the gesture touched her.

Stephanie smiled and decided to reciprocate. She didn’t have any sweets or toys on hand, so she found an old bracelet she rarely wore and a small piece of paper.

Stephanie wrote a note:

“Dear Emily,

Thank you for the candy. I hope you like this bracelet.

Your friend, Stephanie.”

She placed the note and the bracelet under the fence and went back to her gardening, feeling a sense of connection she hadn’t felt in years.

Emily seemed lonely; there were no other children around, and it looked like she was homeschooled. Stephanie thought this small exchange would be the end of it. But the next day, as she was tending to her roses, Mrs. Thompson came storming over, furious.

“What do you think you are doing?” she demanded, her face red with anger. “First ice cream, now a bracelet?! I don’t care what you are planning, but stay away from my daughter!”

Stunned, Stephanie tried to explain herself, “I was just being friendly. Emily seemed to enjoy the ice cream, and I thought—”

But Mrs. Thompson interrupted her, “No! I don’t care what you think. I don’t know you, and I don’t trust you. Keep away from her, do you understand?”

Stephanie nodded, feeling a wave of shame and frustration. She watched as Mrs. Thompson stormed back into her house, slamming the door behind her.

She almost decided to distance herself, but the very next day, she found a plastic lunch bag with coins and a dirty plush bunny with rough stitches under the fence. It had to mean something.

Remembering the last encounter, Stephanie was hesitant to take anything, especially the money. But curiosity got the better of her. She picked up the toy and felt something hard inside.

What could this possibly be? She wondered, holding the bunny carefully, her mind racing with possibilities. The rough stitches seemed to hide something important.

“Emily,” she whispered to herself. “What are you trying to tell me?”

Stephanie brought the toy inside, her heart pounding with curiosity and concern. She carefully stitched apart the plush bunny, hoping not to damage it too much in case it was dear to Emily. From inside the bunny, she pulled out a small kid’s toy phone. It wasn’t a real one, just a piece of plastic with some buttons.

One of the functions was a recorder. Stephanie pressed it, expecting to hear a children’s song. To her surprise, pressing the play button revealed Mrs. Thompson’s voice talking to someone. The audio was poor, but as the toy moved closer to what sounded like a kitchen, her voice became clearer.

“We need that insurance money, John. If we fake an electrical problem, no one will question it. With that weird neighbor woman next door, we could blame it on her watering our electric pole while watering her flowers. Come on, honey, it’s brilliant.”

Stephanie’s eyes widened in shock. She couldn’t believe what she was hearing. Emily had tried to warn her about her mother’s plan in exchange for a bit of kindness. But now that she knew what was going on, she had to do something.

Exposing the recording to the family as proof would only make Emily’s life worse. She considered her options, thinking out loud to herself.

“I could call the insurance company, but I don’t know which company they have a contract with, nor do I know their full names,” she muttered, pacing her living room.

She paused, holding the toy phone, her mind racing. “Besides, Emily’s dad might not have agreed to the scheme that Mrs. Thompson was suggesting. But I can’t risk it. And I doubt that Emily would go that far if he hadn’t.”

Stephanie decided that instead of confronting Mrs. Thompson again, she would take the evidence to the local police. She hoped they would investigate without revealing Emily’s involvement. Gathering her courage, she drove to the police station and explained the situation.

Officer Harris listened carefully as Stephanie laid out the story. “So you found this recording inside a toy bunny that Emily, your mute neighbor, gave you?” he asked, holding up the toy phone.

“Yes, Officer. I believe Emily hid it there to warn me,” Stephanie replied, her voice trembling slightly.

Officer Harris nodded. “Alright, we’ll look into this. Can you leave the toy phone with us?”

“Of course,” Stephanie said, handing it over. “Please, just make sure Emily doesn’t get into trouble.”

A few days later, Stephanie watched from her window as police officers arrived at the Thompsons’ house. They knocked on the door, and Mrs. Thompson answered, her face going pale when she saw the uniforms.

“Good morning, ma’am. We need to ask you a few questions,” one of the officers said.

Mrs. Thompson stammered, “What… what is this about?”

“We received a tip about a potential insurance fraud. May we come in?”

Stephanie watched as the officers entered the house. She couldn’t hear what was being said, but she saw Mr. Thompson join them, looking confused and concerned. After what felt like hours, the officers came out, carrying some documents and looking satisfied with their findings.

Stephanie breathed a sigh of relief, hoping her actions had prevented any harm from coming to Emily. A few days later, Officer Harris came by her house to update her on the situation.

“We’ve looked into the Thompsons. It seems Mrs. Thompson was planning to commit insurance fraud, but Mr. Thompson wasn’t aware of it. Thanks to your tip, we’ve prevented a potential crime.”

Stephanie smiled, feeling a sense of accomplishment. “What’s going to happen to Mrs. Thompson?”

“We’re still investigating, but she’ll likely face charges. As for Emily, we’ve made sure she’s safe,” Officer Harris assured her.

“That’s a relief,” Stephanie said. “Thank you for taking this seriously.”

Officer Harris nodded. “You did the right thing. It’s not easy stepping in, but you probably saved a lot of trouble for that little girl.”

Stephanie watched as the officer left, feeling a weight lift off her shoulders. Later that evening, she saw Emily in her yard, playing with her old, patched-up bunny. Emily looked up and gave Stephanie a small, shy wave.

Stephanie waved back, smiling warmly. “Hi, Emily. How are you?”

Emily didn’t respond verbally, but she ran over to the fence, holding up a drawing she’d made. It was a simple picture of two figures holding hands, surrounded by flowers.

Stephanie felt tears prick in her eyes. “That’s beautiful, Emily. Thank you.”

Emily beamed, her silent gratitude speaking louder than words ever could. Stephanie knew they’d both come through a difficult ordeal, but their bond had grown stronger because of it.

Stephanie hoped that in time, Emily’s life would be filled with more kindness and less fear and that she could continue being a source of support for her brave little neighbor.

As the sun set, casting a warm glow over the neighborhood, Stephanie felt a sense of peace. She had done the right thing, and for the first time in a long while, she felt like she was part of something bigger than herself: a small but important part of Emily’s world.

What would you have done differently if you were in Stephanie’s place? While you’re busy contemplating your response, you might want to check out another exciting read below:

My sister-in-law Emily’s birthday gift, an ugly garden gnome, seemed harmless enough. But three days later, a furious stranger showed up at my door, accusing me of stealing and demanding the return of her beloved “Rupert.” What did Emily do?!

This work is inspired by real events and people, but it has been fictionalized for creative purposes. Names, characters, and details have been changed to protect privacy and enhance the narrative. Any resemblance to actual persons, living or dead, or actual events is purely coincidental and not intended by the author.

The author and publisher make no claims to the accuracy of events or the portrayal of characters and are not liable for any misinterpretation. This story is provided “as is,” and any opinions expressed are those of the characters and do not reflect the views of the author or publisher.